Sunday, August 18, 2024

Final Blog Reflection

While blogging is definitely not something I am overly familiar with, I think my blog reflects a deep engagement with existing knowledge, integrating evidence-based findings from class content, personal research and experience, and external sources. Each post showcases a commitment to exploring educational themes from multiple perspectives, including diversity, historical context, and Indigenous knowledge. This approach emphasizes a humanistic pedagogical foundation that values experiential learning and the inclusion of student voices within the constraints of the curriculum. 

A significant takeaway from my reflections is the importance of using research-based strategies to create inclusive and supportive learning environments. This comprehensive approach not only enhances understanding but also encourages a more nuanced perspective on the complexities of teaching and learning.

The blog also demonstrates clear connections with class content, illustrating how literature and resources have influenced my scholarly and practical approaches. For example, the readings by Bourn (2021) and Chanicka, Mahari de Silva, and Merkley (2018) have profoundly impacted my understanding of educational innovation, creativity, and transformative learning. Bourn’s article emphasizes the need for educational strategies that go beyond passive learning, advocating for a shift to dynamic, participatory methods aligned with real-world issues and social change. This perspective resonates with my understanding of creativity as integrating social justice and practical engagement into the curriculum, fostering critical thinking and problem-solving. Chanicka et al. complement this view by promoting co-constructive learning, where students and teachers collaboratively engage in knowledge creation, enhancing both inclusivity and student creativity. Their focus on integrating social justice frameworks into inquiry-based learning aligns with the need for educational practices that address contemporary societal needs.

The evolution of my blog throughout the course highlights significant personal and professional growth. Initially, I struggled with technology and engagement but have since developed a more effective and reflective blogging approach. Feedback and discussions with peers have expanded my understanding, particularly regarding traditionally knowledge and Indigenous perspectives in education (a topic I am unfamiliar with but find immensely interested in).

Creating a personal learning network and sharing my blog has marked a transformative shift from passive knowledge absorption to active contribution within educational communities. This platform has allowed me to gather and share resources, strategies, and tools, enhancing my professional development and engagement. By actively participating in learning communities and reflecting on my experiences, my blog has become a space for continuous growth, where creativity, innovation, and reflection converge, demonstrating my progress and commitment to advancing educational practices. However, I would have enjoyed more comments and opportunities to share perspectives.

References:

Bourn, D. (2021) ‘Pedagogy of hope: global learning and the future of education.’     International Journal of Development Education and Global Learning, 13 (2), 65–78. DOI: https://doi.org/10.14324/ IJDEGL.13.2.01.

Chanicka, Jeewan, et al. “An inclusive design vision for Canada – schooling as a process for participatory democracy and responsible citizenship.” Intercultural Education, vol. 29, no. 5–6, Oct. 2018, pp. 632–646, https://doi.org/10.1080/14675986.2018.1508620.


Professional Development in Practice

A couple of weeks ago I attended a webinar hosted by the British Council titled "How can we use technology to make engaging listening activities?” The webinar was hosted by Chiara Bruzzano who is an English Language Teaching researcher and teacher trainer. The webinar highlighted the often-overlooked skill of listening in language learning, focusing on both bottom-up decoding and top-down meaning building. It addressed common issues like word segmentation and misinterpretations due to preconceptions. Traditional methods emphasizing testing were critiqued, and innovative strategies using YouTube features, Chrome extensions, and interactive tools were proposed. These approaches aim to improve engagement, comprehension, and metacognitive awareness in listening practice.

Since the webinar, I've integrated tools like Language Reactor for real-time translations and YouTube captions and speed controls to manage speech pace. Using bookmarking tools like Bookmark Youtube has allowed students to identify and focus on challenging segments. These changes have made listening activities more engaging and effective in my EFL classroom. My listening classes are now much more enjoyable for my students, they have expressed to me how the tool YouGlish has helped them with understanding native pronunciations. Listening is often the skill that all students dread and one they have the most difficulty with, but these tools make it less daunting and easier for the students to grade listening based on their ability, while also challenging themselves.

Is innovation possible in Eikaiwa Schools?

I currently teach at a large eikaiwa in Osaka, Japan. Eikaiwa are private language schools are unique educational environments designed to enhance English language skills through conversation practice. Despite their structured approach, these schools present distinct challenges when it comes to integrating innovation and creativity into teaching practices. 

One of the most striking aspects of working in an eikaiwa is the balance between adhering to established curricula and injecting creative, innovative methods into lessons. Eikaiwas typically follow a set syllabus and use pre-designed materials, which can limit opportunities for creativity. This rigidity, while ensuring consistency and alignment with educational standards, can stifle the freedom needed for innovative teaching.

Innovation in the eikaiwa context involves more than just introducing new technologies or methodologies. It requires a nuanced approach to adapt the existing framework to better engage students and meet their diverse needs. After reading Chanlin, L.-J. (2017), Analysis of teachers’ tablet teaching adoption process. Educational Sciences : Theory & Practice, I saw the importance of using technology (in this case, tablets) to provide personalized learning experiences that cater to the diverse needs of students. For instance, incorporating interactive tools like language learning apps or using multimedia resources can enrich the traditional conversation-focused model. However, integrating such tools is often met with resistance due to the established nature of eikaiwa curricula and the limited flexibility in adapting lesson plans.

Creativity, on the other hand, often struggles against the constraints of a standardized teaching environment. In an eikaiwa, where the primary focus is on conversation practice, there is limited room for exploring unconventional teaching methods or designing highly personalized lessons. The challenge is to inspire creativity within a framework that prioritizes consistent, measurable outcomes. This can be particularly challenging when the primary goal is to prepare students for standardized tests or specific language milestones.

Despite these challenges, there are moments of breakthrough where creativity and innovation shine through. For example, developing themed conversation classes based on current events or students' interests can make lessons more engaging, especially for adult classes. Encouraging students to create their own content, such as dialogue scenarios or role-playing activities, allows for a more dynamic and student-centered approach. Kids especially like to take control or, at least, feel in control of their own learning. These instances of innovation not only enhance student engagement but also provide a sense of fulfillment in breaking away from the monotony of traditional methods.

References:

ChanLin, L.-J. (2017). Analysis of teachers’ tablet teaching adoption process. Educational Sciences: Theory & Practice, 17(6), 1935-1958 https://web-p-ebscohost-com.proxy.queensu.ca/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=0&sid=42c9d2b9-a755-4407-9a26-333e3d8e9e1c%40redis

Final Learning Glossary and Reflection

 Innovation

Original Definition:

Innovation is the creation of a novel idea that improves upon, updates and/or renews a current solution to a problem. It utilizes critical thinking and creativity, resulting in a solution that fosters advancements that may transform entire industries. 

Revised Definition:

Innovation is the creation of a novel idea or approach that not only improves or renews a current solution to a problem but also challenges traditional systems and practices. This form of innovation emphasizes critical thinking, reflexivity, and dialogue, leading to solutions that are economically beneficial and socially transformative.

Reflection

Through the course readings and peer interaction, I have refined my personal definition of innovation. I realized that innovation was not only about updating or renewing a solution to a problem, but crucially, moving away from established norms and embracing collaborative, interpretive processes that fosters advancements that empower individuals, promote social change, and enrich the future. I was particularly influenced by the perspective of Bourn (2021), who stated “Learning is anti-oppressive and encourages reflexivity, dialogue, and criticality.” While my first definition focused on creating novel solutions that foster advancements and potentially transform industries, the new definition expands the purpose of innovation to include social transformation. It emphasizes that innovation should not only improve current solutions but also contribute to social change and empowerment, aligning with the idea that learning and teaching should go beyond economic growth.

Creativity

Original Definition:

Creativity to me is using one’s imagination to create something novel that transcends convention and traditional boundaries. 

Revised Definition:

Creativity is the collaborative process of using imagination to create something novel that challenges conventional boundaries. It involves co-constructive learning, where students and teachers engage in inquiry-based practices to explore ideas, foster social change, and envision a more just and equitable world in a way that adds value to students’ lives. 

Reflection:

This new definition of creativity expands beyond the individual act of using imagination to transcend conventional boundaries, as in the previous definition. It emphasizes collaboration between students and teachers in co-constructive learning, where creativity becomes a shared process. Like innovation, my new definition also connects creativity to broader social goals, such as fostering social change and equity, rather than focusing solely on the creation of something novel. This shift highlights the importance of creativity in education as a tool for addressing social justice and empowering students to contribute to a more just world. It also is important for education to be meaningful and  “add value to students’ lives” (Chanicka et al., 2018), which is highlighted in the revised definition.

Teaching

Original Definition:

Teaching to me is imparting/transferring knowledge by facilitating an atmosphere of curiosity, creativity and collaboration, allowing students to be a part of the learning process. My views on teaching are student-centred, with students being active participants in the learning process, with teachers acting as facilitators and leaders to guide the attainment of knowledge. Teaching also demands a level of trust and building positive relationships in which teachers support and cultivate understanding.

Revised Definition:

Teaching involves not just transferring knowledge but integrating historical and contemporary practices to create adaptive learning environments. It requires a balance of reflection and action, where teachers facilitate creativity, curiosity, and collaboration. By inspiring students to engage in intellectual exploration, teaching fosters a lifelong commitment to learning and innovation.

Reflection:

The new definition incorporates the importance of integrating historical and contemporary practices to create adaptive learning environments. It emphasizes the unity of reflection and practice, as well as the need for teachers to inspire intellectual exploration and foster a lifelong commitment to learning and innovation. This new definition links it to broader, practical educational strategies and the importance of adapting to diverse needs, rather than solely focusing on the student-centered approach and the relational aspects of teaching, as highlighted in Herbst, J. (1999), The history of education: State and the art at the turn of the century in Europe and North America. Additionally, I decided to add the importance of teachers as facilitators of inspiration. It is essential that students do not view education as a means to an end but as an intellectual journey that should be met with enthusiasm.

Learning

Original Definition:

My definition of learning is the ability to attain and retain new knowledge, understanding, skills or techniques to solve problems and grow as an individual. 

Revised Definition:

Learning is a continuous journey that goes beyond formal education, involving daily interactions and real-world applications. It fosters critical thinking and empowers individuals to drive meaningful change. This holistic approach enriches personal growth and societal engagement, emphasizing the integration of knowledge with practical action.

Reflection:

I felt my original definition was limited and was lacking in more diverse and dynamic perspectives. While the original definition emphasizes the ability to gain new skills and solve problems, the updated view highlights learning as an ongoing, real-world process intertwined with daily experiences. It highlights the importance of critical thinking, practical application, and personal and societal impact, rather than just individual growth. This approach views learning as a holistic, lifelong journey that integrates cognitive processes with real-world challenges, reflecting a more expansive and interactive understanding of how learning enriches and engages individuals with their environment. An example of this are Madden (2015) and Ball’s (2004) perspectives on Indigenous education and the emphasis on respect for Indigenous wisdom and traditional methods of teaching and learning. By engaging community teaching alongside traditional academic content, educators could create a more inclusive and culturally relevant educational environment, highlighting the importance of societal and cultural engagement.





References


Ball, J. (2004). As If Indigenous Knowledge and Communities Mattered: Transformative Education in First Nations Communities in Canada. American Indian Quarterly, 28(3/4), 454–479. https://doi.org/10.1353/aiq.2004.0090

Bourn, D. (2021). Pedagogy of hope: global learning and the future of education. International Journal of Development Education and Global Learning, 13(2), 65–78. https://doi.org/10.14324/IJDEGL.13.2.01

Chanicka, Jeewan, et al. “An inclusive design vision for Canada – schooling as a process for participatory democracy and responsible citizenship.” Intercultural Education, vol. 29, no. 5–6, Oct. 2018, pp. 632–646, https://doi.org/10.1080/14675986.2018.1508620.

Herbst, J. (1999). The history of education: State and the art at the turn of the century in Europe and North America. Paedegogia Historica: International Journal of the History of Education, 35(3), 737–-47. doi: 10.1080/0030923990350308 

Madden, B. (2015). Pedagogical pathways for Indigenous education with/in teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 51, 1–15. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2015.05.005 


Professional Development Reflection

 


Event Information

The professional development event that I decided for this reflection was a section of the Multimodal Classrooms Mini Event hosted by the British Council on August 1st at 6:15 - 7:15. It was an interactive webinar called “How can we use technology to make engaging listening activities?” and was presented by Chiara Bruzzano and English Language Teaching (ELT) researcher and teacher trainer. 

Event Description

The webinar focused on the often-neglected skill of listening in language learning, highlighting its importance and exploring effective strategies for teaching it. Designed for language educators, the event discussed the dual process of listening—bottom-up decoding and top-down meaning building—and the challenges learners face, such as difficulties with word segmentation (being unable to distinguish individual words when listening) and preconceptions leading to misinterpretations. The webinar critiqued traditional listening instruction methods that emphasize testing over teaching and presented innovative approaches to enhance student engagement and control in listening practice. By leveraging technology, such as YouTube features, Chrome extensions, and interactive tools, the webinar provided practical suggestions to help educators create more effective and differentiated listening activities that address both bottom-up and top-down skills. Attendees were encouraged to adopt these tools to improve listening comprehension, foster metacognitive awareness, and ultimately, make listening a more active and enjoyable part of language learning.

Reaction to the Event and Ties to Practice

As an EFL teacher, I found the webinar incredibly insightful and valuable, particularly because it shed light on the often overlooked skill of listening, which is crucial for language acquisition and often overlooked by teachers and curricula. The discussion on the dual process of listening, which are bottom-up decoding and top-down meaning building, was very interesting to me as it highlighted the complexities my students face when processing spoken language. As addressed in the session by the speaker and participants, most of the listening exercises teachers implement focus more on testing comprehension, such as gap fills and comprehension questions, rather than teaching the skill itself. The critique of traditional listening instruction challenged me to rethink my approach. 

What I found most valuable were the practical tools and strategies introduced during the webinar, especially those involving technology. The idea of using YouTube features, such as captions and adjustable playback speed, along with Chrome extensions like Language Reactor and Bookmark YouTube, offered innovative ways to make listening exercises more engaging and differentiated for my students. I did note that these features would be most appropriately applied to online classes or classes in which technology is available in the classroom. I was especially impressed by the online tools YouGlish for hearing natural and realistic examples of English phrases. I also found the tools lyricstraining.com and tubequizard as great supplements to listening exercises that can be used to “gamify” listening and make lessons more engaging. These tools not only help in developing listening skills but also empower students to take control of their learning, something I strive to encourage in my classroom.

Overall, the webinar provided me with actionable ideas to enhance my teaching practice and helped me see new possibilities for making listening an active, enjoyable, and integral part of my students' language learning journey.

Artifacts to Demonstrate Impact

The following are artifacts I created to demonstrate the practical applications that I derived from attending the professional development webinar. They consist of a lesson plan that I utilized in the past as an EAP teacher and the revision of that plan using some of the principles I acquired from the webinar. In addition, I’ve included a new lesson plan based off of some of the techniques I’ve learned.

Original Lesson Plan


Lesson: Academic Listening for C1/C2 EAP class.


Purpose: To become familiar with academic speech patterns and identify key themes and main points.


Procedure: 


1. Lead in: 


  • Have students discuss the following questions: 

  1. How do you define “security?” 

  2. What situations do you feel safe/unsafe?


2. Pre-Listening:


  • Elicit comprehension questions from students and check understanding:

1) What are the two different concepts of security

2) How does the concept of Saddam Hussein illustrate his point?

3) What kinds of activities do we do every day that involve risk?

4) Why are we so bad at making security trade-off decisions?

5) What are the 4 biases in risk perception that he mentions?

6) What do newspapers do and what effect does this have on people?

7) What is “security theatre”?

8) What should companies do? What are 2 ways they can do this?

9) What is a model? What are some examples?

10) How do different generations view risks of electricity differently? Why?

11) Why did Swine Flu cause so much fear? What happened over time?

12) What are some other examples of models changing?

13) What is confirmation bias?

14) What are some things that can create a model?

15) What are 2 ways to fix the problem?


3. Listening:


  • Play recording with subtitles activated at 0.75% speed, and stop at 5:00 mark to allow students to think about answers. Repeat process for 10:00 and 15:00.


4. Post-Listening:


  • Have students compare notes and discuss answers to the comprehension questions together.

  • Take up answers as a class, eliciting answers from students.


5. Discussion:


  • Review discussion questions as a class. Model answers to one or more question:

  1. Do you think that the world has overreacted to the threat of COVID-19? Is the model close to reality?

  2. Has our model about COVID-19 changed since the initial outbreak in December?

  3. Why do some people (anti vaxxers) fear/distrust vaccines? Is this common in your country?

  4. What are some “flashbulb events” you have in your memory?

  5. Do you have any fears? How close to reality is your feelings about the fear?

  6. "we respond to feelings of security rather than the reality of security"


Revised Lesson Plan


Lesson: Academic Listening for C1/C2 EAP class.


Purpose: To become familiar with academic speech patterns and identify key themes and main points.


Procedure: 


1. Lead in: 


  • Have students discuss the following questions: 

  1. How do you define “security?” 

  2. What situations do you feel safe/unsafe?


2. Pre-Listening:


  • Elicit comprehension questions from students and check understanding:

1) What are the two different concepts of security

2) Why are we so bad at making security trade-off decisions?

3) What are the 4 biases in risk perception that he mentions?

4) What is “security theatre”?

5) What is a model? What are some examples?

6) How do different generations view risks of electricity differently? Why?

7) Why did Swine Flu cause so much fear? What happened over time?

8) What are some things that can create a model?


3. Listening


  • Give students 30 minutes to watch video individually, at their own pace. Instruct them that they may use the speed and transcript feature on YouTube, as well as Bookmark Youtube to pinpoint where they think the answer to each question is in the recording.

  • Ask them to make note of phrases or words that are unfamiliar


4. Post-Listening

  • Have students compare notes and discuss answers to the comprehension questions together.

  • Take up answers as a class, eliciting answers from students.

  • Elicit some vocabulary or phrases that the students were unfamiliar with, make a list on the whiteboard and instruct the students to use YouGlish to hear further examples in other videos and definitions.

  • Elicit the definition of the words from the students.


5. Discussion


  • Review discussion questions as a class. Model answers to one or more question:

  1. Do you think that the world has overreacted to the threat of COVID-19? Is the model close to reality?

  2. Has our model about COVID-19 changed since the initial outbreak in December?

  3. Why do some people (anti vaxxers) fear/distrust vaccines? Is this common in your country?

  4. What are some “flashbulb events” you have in your memory?

  5. Do you have any fears? How close to reality is your feelings about the fear?

  6. "we respond to feelings of security rather than the reality of security"

6. Reflection and Metacognition:

  • Have students fill out a Google Form with reflection questions, such as:

    • How difficult was the listening exercise today?

    • What was the most challenging part for you?

    • Which words or phrases did you find difficult?

    • What is one thing you could do to improve your listening next time?

  • Use their responses to guide a brief class discussion on strategies to improve listening skills.

New Lesson Plan


Lesson: Listening for A1/A2 English class


Purpose: To become familiar with native speech patterns 


Procedure: 

1. Warm-Up:

  • Ask students to share their experiences with listening in English. What challenges do they face?

2. Listening:

  • Video Selection: Play a short, simple YouTube video (1-2 minutes) relevant to the students' interests (e.g., a clip from a children's show, a simple recipe, or a short travel vlog).

  • First Listening:

    • Students listen to the video without captions. Ask them to focus on understanding the general idea (top-down processing).

    • After listening, have a brief discussion on what they understood. Elicit key points and write them on the whiteboard.

  • Second Listening:

    • Enable captions and play the video again, this time with students paying attention to specific words and phrases (bottom-up processing).

    • Elicit difficult words from students and use the Language Reactor extension to click on difficult words for translations and examples. Pause the video when necessary to discuss these words and their meanings.

3. Bookmarking Difficulties:

  • Introduce students to the Bookmark YouTube extension. Explain that they will use it to mark moments in the video where they had difficulty understanding.

  • Play the video a third time, asking students to bookmark key moments using the extension. Encourage them to think about why those moments were challenging (e.g., fast speech, unknown vocabulary, pronunciation).

4. Intensive Listening and Decoding:

  • Focus on a short extract from the video (5-10 seconds) where students had difficulties.

  • Play this segment multiple times at a slower speed. Ask students to identify specific sounds, syllables, and words (bottom-up decoding).

  • Discuss as a class what they noticed (eg.”a lot of” is pronounced “alotta”) and how it helped them understand the segment better.

5. Reflection and Metacognition:

  • Have students fill out a Google Form with reflection questions, such as:

    • How difficult was the listening exercise today?

    • What was the most challenging part for you?

    • Which words or phrases did you find difficult?

    • What is one thing you could do to improve your listening next time?

  • Use their responses to guide a brief class discussion on strategies to improve listening skills.

Recommended Audience

I would recommend this professional development activity to EFL teachers who are looking to deepen their understanding of how listening skills can be effectively taught and developed in their students. It is particularly valuable for educators who feel that listening is often overlooked in favor of other macro skills, like reading, writing, and speaking. This activity provides a thorough exploration of the complexities of listening, including both bottom-up decoding and top-down meaning-building processes, and it highlights common challenges learners face, such as word segmentation and top-down fabrication. Additionally, the activity offers practical strategies and technological tools, such as YouTube features and Chrome extensions, to enhance listening instruction and make it more engaging. Teachers who want to move beyond the traditional comprehension approach to listening and instead focus on actively developing their students’ listening skills will find this activity especially beneficial.